Failure to Identify is a criminal offense that occurs when a person refuses to provide their identifying personal information after a lawful arrest or gives false information to law enforcement during an arrest, detention, or as a witness to a crime.

A Failure to Identify conviction doesn’t just go away—it can stay on your record, affect job opportunities, and even impact future legal matters. If you don’t act quickly, you could be facing harsher penalties than expected.

Don’t Let a Mistake Ruin Your Future—speak with our Dallas criminal defense lawyer today.

Contact Us

Understanding Texas Penal Code 38.02

A common misconception is that individuals always provide their identity to police officers. However, Texas law does not require a person to identify themselves unless they have been lawfully arrested or are operating a motor vehicle.

That said, under Texas Penal Code 38.02, providing false personal information to law enforcement, even during detention, is a separate offense with more severe penalties.

Two Ways to Commit the Offense

Refusing to Provide Identifying Information After a Lawful Arrest

  • If a person has been lawfully arrested and intentionally refuses to provide their name, address, or date of birth when asked by law enforcement, they can be charged with a Class C misdemeanor.
  • A Class C misdemeanor carries a maximum fine of $500 but does not include jail time.

Providing False Information During an Arrest, Detention, or as a Witness

If a person intentionally provides false or fictitious identifying information to a police officer when:

  • Under lawful arrest
  • Lawfully detained
  • Questioned as a witness to a criminal offense

They can be charged with a Class B misdemeanor, punishable by up to 180 days in jail and a fine of up to $2,000.

Additionally, if the person was a fugitive at the time of the offense, the charge is elevated by one level (e.g., Class C becomes Class B, and Class B becomes Class A).

Key Elements of Texas Penal Code 38.02

Lawful Arrest vs. Mere Detention

  • Lawful Arrest: If you are formally arrested, you are legally required to provide your name, address, and date of birth when asked by an officer. Refusing to do so can result in a Failure to Identify charge.
  • Mere Detention: If you are only detained (but not necessarily arrested), you do not have to provide your identity. However, lying about their identity while detained is still considered a crime.

Intentional Refusal vs. Accidental Non-Compliance

  • Intentional Refusal: The law applies only if the person knowingly and deliberately refuses to provide their information or provides false details.
  • Accidental Non-Compliance: If a person genuinely forgets their date of birth or makes an honest mistake, their attorney may argue that their actions were unintentional, which could help in defending against the charge.

A Failure to Identify a charge can have lasting consequences. Let our defense lawyer help you fight it

Contact Us

Penalties for Failure to Identify in Texas

The severity of penalties for a Failure to Identify a charge depends on the circumstances of the offense. Texas law classifies this crime into different misdemeanor levels, with penalties ranging from fines to possible jail time.

Class C Misdemeanor – Refusal to Identify

A person commits a Class C misdemeanor if they intentionally refuse to provide their name, residence address, or date of birth after a lawful arrest when requested by law enforcement. This is the least severe charge under Texas Penal Code 38.02.

  • Punishable by a fine of up to $500
  • No jail time

Class B Misdemeanor – Providing False Information

A person commits a Class B misdemeanor if they intentionally provide false or fictitious identifying information when:

  • Under lawful arrest
  • Lawfully detained
  • Questioned as a witness to a crime

This charge carries more serious consequences than refusing to identify.

  • Punishable by up to 180 days in jail
  • Fine of up to $2,000

Class A Misdemeanor – Failure to Identify (Fugitive Status)

If the person charged with Failure to Identify had an outstanding warrant at the time of the offense, the charge is elevated to a Class A misdemeanor.

  • Punishable by up to one year in jail
  • Fine of up to $4,000

Reach out to our Dallas misdemeanor lawyer at your earliest opportunity for expert legal support

Contact Us

Common Misconceptions About Failure to Identify

Many people misunderstand their rights when it comes to identifying themselves to law enforcement. This confusion often leads to unnecessary arrests and criminal charges. Below, we clarify some of the most common misconceptions about Failure to Identify in Texas and provide fictional scenarios to illustrate each point.

Do I Have to Identify Myself If I Am Detained?

No—unless you are driving or under arrest. In Texas, if you’re detained, such as during a traffic stop or police investigation, you are not legally required to provide that information or identification unless you are operating a motor vehicle. However, lying about your identity during a detention is a separate offense.

Scenario: John is walking home when a police officer stops him and asks for his name. John is not driving and is not under arrest. He politely declines to provide his name and asks if he is free to leave. The officer has no legal grounds to force John to identify himself, so he lets him go.

What If I Remain Silent?

Remaining silent is not a crime, but lying about your identity is. You have the right to remain silent under the Fifth Amendment. However, if you choose to speak and intentionally give false information, you can be charged under Texas Penal Code 38.02.

Scenario: Maria is arrested for a minor offense. When the officer asks for her name, she refuses to speak. Because silence is not a criminal act, she is not charged with Failure to Identify. However, if she had given a fake name, she could face additional charges.

Can I Refuse to Show ID?

Yes—if you’re not driving, but refusing to provide information after an arrest is a chargeable offense. Texas does not have a general “stop and identify” law, meaning that outside of driving situations, law enforcement officers cannot demand to see your ID unless you are under arrest.

Scenario: David is a passenger in a car pulled over for a traffic violation. The officer asks for his ID, but David refuses. Because he is not the driver, he is not legally required to provide ID, and refusing to do so is not a crime. However, if David had been arrested and then refused to provide his information, he could be charged with Failure to Identify (Class C misdemeanor).

police officers speaking with arrested person

Defenses Against Failure to Identify Charges

At the Law Offices of Richard C. McConathy, our defense strategies focus on challenging the circumstances of your arrest and ensuring that law enforcement followed proper legal procedures.

Below are some key defenses we will use to fight Failure to Identify charges on your behalf.

Unlawful Arrest or Detention

If the initial stop or arrest was unlawful, any charges stemming from it—including Failure to Identify—may not hold up in court. Police officers must have reasonable suspicion to detain someone and probable cause to make an arrest.

Scenario: An officer detains Jake without reasonable suspicion and later charges him with Failure to Identify after he refuses to provide his name. If we can prove that the initial detention was illegal, we can file a motion to dismiss the charge, as it was based on an unlawful police stop.

Lack of Intent

The law requires that a person intentionally refuses to provide their name or knowingly provides false information. If the prosecution cannot prove intent, the charge may not stand.

Scenario: Sarah was arrested and asked for her date of birth. Due to nerves, she accidentally gave the wrong year. Because her mistake was not intentional, we can argue that the charge should be dropped.

Violation of Rights

Law enforcement is required to inform you of your rights and follow proper legal procedures when making an arrest. If an officer fails to provide a Miranda warning or gives misleading information about your legal rights, it may be grounds for a constitutional challenge in your case.

Scenario: A police officer tells Michael that he must provide his ID during a routine pedestrian stop, even though he is not driving or under arrest. If the officer misrepresented the law, we could argue that Michael’s charge should be thrown out due to a violation of his rights.

Contact Our Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers

If you have been charged with Failure to Identify in Texas, acting quickly is essential. Even a minor misdemeanor can lead to fines, jail time, and a permanent criminal record, which can affect your job, housing, and future legal matters.

Our experienced criminal defense lawyer can help protect your rights, fight for a case dismissal, or negotiate reduced penalties.

At our law firm, we have successfully defended countless clients against Failure to Identify charges:

  • Failure to I.D, Dismissed, Dallas County, M13-17096
  • Failure to I.D., Dismissed, Dallas County, M14-20419
  • Failure to I.D/Fictitious Information, Not Guilty, Ellis County, 1311751CR

Our legal team will examine the details of your case, challenge unlawful arrests, and build a strong defense on your behalf.

Call us at (972) 445-9909
Email us at info@mcconathylaw.com

Don’t risk a criminal record—schedule a free consultation with our Texas criminal defense attorney today.

Contact Us

Final Points

  • Failure to Identify is a misdemeanor offense under Texas Penal Code 38.02, carrying penalties that range from fines to jail time.
  • You are not required to identify yourself unless you are driving or under arrest, but lying to police can result in additional charges.
  • Common defenses include unlawful arrest, lack of intent, and violation of rights.
  • Our experienced criminal defense attorney can help reduce charges, fight for a dismissal, or negotiate a favorable outcome.

If you’re facing a Failure to Identify charge, don’t risk handling it alone. Our legal representation will make all the difference.

FAQs

Do I have to identify myself to police in Texas?

In Texas, you have to identify yourself only if you are under arrest or driving a motor vehicle. If you’ve been detained and not driving, you are not legally required to provide your name. However, lying about your identity can result in criminal charges.

No, Texas law does not require individuals to carry an ID unless they are operating a vehicle. However, if you are lawfully arrested, you must provide your name, date of birth, and residence address. Refusing to do so can result in a Class C misdemeanor charge.

If you accidentally provide incorrect information (such as a wrong birth date due to nerves), you may be able to argue lack of intent as a defense. Failure to Identify requires intent, meaning the prosecution must prove you knowingly gave false information. Our defense attorney can help argue that it was an honest mistake.